Major Kudos
"I love Tosco's. It's so good my boyfriend proposed to me after we ate there. He's like, "I'm so glad you said 'yes' ... and I'm like I didn't say yes I said "okay" -- lol. 

The pizza here is excellent - if you get meat or vegetable surprise pizza its like 500 pounds of toppings -- I love it!
~ Plates P. 
"This place is far more than pizza! FANTASTIC pasta dishes and more!"
~ JB

"Loved this place. Nothing fancy but really solid NY style pizza and super friendly staff. Also mention it's beyond reasonably priced!"
~ Sherry
"The BEST thing to happen to food in this part of Ulster County in a very long time. The pizza is the best I've had in this area, and the subs/burgers have all been amazing. The Mexican dishes blew my mind, everything seems to be made to a gourmet quality.... and they deliver!! Somebody call Guy Fieri, this place is for real."
~ Jaset
"I ordered pick up with a friend of mine from here last night and was thoroughly impressed. We decided to have a mini feast and ordered a lot of different things. A large pizza, a dozen wings, garlic bread, and six of their huge garlic knots. Everything was really delicious ... the price point and quality of food is what would bring me back in here."
~ Gordon

"The largest regular slice that I've seen in a long time. The Sicilian pizza is delicious.The prices are reasonable."
~ John
"Good tasty pizza, reasonable prices. Lots of specialty pies available by the slice. Try the shrimp oreganata, the eggplant, the chicken marsala, the sausage pepper and onion or just a plain slice! So many choices, so little time.

This location went through a number of pizza type places over the years but this one got it right and should be around for a long time. Young guy who owns the place is usually around and is very pleasant and responsive to any request."
~ Paul
Share by: